Smart Router: Context-Aware Tool Selection

Overview

When multiple plugins can handle the same task, smart routing ensures the best tool is selected based on context and user preferences. This skill loads the agent registry, analyzes the current situation, ranks available tools, and either auto-routes or presents ranked options.

When This Skill Activates

Use this skill when:

• routing-detector hook suggests "ACTION: Use smart-router skill"
• User has multiple tools for the same capability (3+ code review agents, 2+ brainstorming skills, etc.)
• User asks "which tool should I use?" or "what's best for this?"
• Multiple capabilities detected in a single request

Do NOT use this skill when:

• Only one tool is available (just use it)
• User explicitly named a specific tool/plugin
• No routing-detector suggestion appeared

Process

Step 1: Load Registry and Settings

Read the agent registry and user preferences:

# Registry location (auto-generated by SessionStart hook)
.claude/.cache/agent-registry.json

# User preferences (if exists)
.claude/smart-router.local.md

Registry structure:

{
  "capabilities": {
    "code-review": [
      {
        "plugin": "superpowers",
        "type": "skill",
        "entry": "skills/code-reviewer/SKILL.md",
        "description": "...",
        "source": "global"
      }
    ]
  }
}

Settings structure:

---
routingMode: auto          # auto | ask | context
showReasoning: true        # Show why tool was chosen
excludePlugins:            # Plugins to ignore
  - plugin-name
priorityOrder:             # Override default ranking
  - superpowers
  - pr-review-toolkit
---

Step 2: Identify Relevant Capabilities

Based on user prompt, determine which capabilities are needed. The routing-detector hook already identified these, but validate:

Common capabilities:

• code-review - Code review, PR review, code quality
• brainstorming - Design, ideation, planning, architecture
• testing - Test generation, QA, test coverage
• debugging - Debug, troubleshoot, fix bugs
• refactoring - Code cleanup, reorganization
• game-development - Game mechanics, Unity/Unreal/Godot
• backend-development - APIs, microservices, backend
• frontend-development - UI, React, components
• conversation-search - Search past conversations, memory

Step 3: Collect Matching Tools

From registry, collect all tools matching the identified capabilities.

Filter out:

• Plugins in excludePlugins setting
• Tools with obviously wrong context (e.g., don't suggest game-dev for API code)

Step 4: Rank Tools by Context

Rank tools using this priority order:

1. User Priority Order (Highest Priority)

If settings define priorityOrder, respect it first - user knows their workflow best:

priorityOrder:
  - superpowers
  - pr-review-toolkit
  - feature-dev

Example: If user set superpowers first, always prefer superpowers tools when available.

2. Tool Specialty (High Priority)

From description field, prefer specialized tools:

• PR-specific reviewer > general code reviewer
• Game-specific debugger > general debugger
• Test generator for APIs > general test tool

Example: pr-review-toolkit (specialized for PR review) ranks higher than generic code reviewer, even if working on game files.

Why specialty matters: Specialized tools exist because they're better at specific tasks. Don't override specialty based on file context alone.

3. File Context (Medium Priority)

Analyze files in current directory and recently modified files:

# Check file types
*.cs, *.unity, *.prefab → Prefer game-development tools
*.tsx, *.jsx, *.css → Prefer frontend tools
*.py, *.go, *.ts (backend) → Prefer backend tools
*.test.ts, *.spec.js → Prefer testing tools

Example: When choosing between two game-dev tools with equal specialty, prefer the one matching file context.

4. Tool Type (Low Priority)

When tied, prefer in this order:

1. Skills (most flexible)
2. Agents (specialized)
3. Commands (manual invocation)
4. Workflows (local, project-specific)

5. Alphabetical (Tie-Breaker)

If still tied, sort alphabetically by plugin name.

Step 5: Route Based on Mode

Read routingMode from settings (default: context):

Mode: auto

Automatically select the top-ranked tool and use it directly. No questions, no menu.

Output:

🎯 Smart Router: Auto-routing to [plugin-name]

Reason: [Brief explanation of why this tool was chosen]

[Proceeding with the task using this tool...]

Then: Use the Skill tool or invoke the agent/command directly.

Mode: ask

Present ranked options as a numbered menu, let user choose.

Output:

🎯 Smart Router: Multiple Tools Available

Based on your task and context, here are your options (ranked):

1. ⭐ superpowers:code-reviewer (RECOMMENDED)
   Type: Skill
   Why: General purpose, matches your file context (TypeScript backend)
   Description: Comprehensive code review with TDD focus

2. pr-review-toolkit:code-reviewer
   Type: Agent
   Why: Specialized for PR review workflows
   Description: Multi-aspect PR analysis (comments, tests, errors)

3. feature-dev:code-reviewer
   Type: Agent
   Why: Feature branch focused
   Description: Reviews feature branches before merge

Which tool would you like to use? (1-3)

Then: Wait for user response and use selected tool.

Mode: context

Use file context to make automatic decision, but show brief reasoning:

Output:

🎯 Smart Router: Context-aware routing

Detected context: TypeScript backend API files
Routing to: pr-review-toolkit:code-reviewer
Reason: Specialized for API code review

[Proceeding...]

Then: Use the selected tool.

Step 6: Execute Routing Decision

Once tool is selected, invoke it using the appropriate method:

For Skills:

Skill tool: plugin-name:skill-name

For Agents:

Task tool (subagent_type): plugin-name:agent-name

For Commands:

/plugin-name:command-name

For Workflows (local):

SlashCommand: /path/to/workflow.md

Advanced: Multi-Capability Scenarios

When user request spans multiple capabilities (e.g., "build a game with backend API"):

Option 1: Suggest Parallel Dispatch

If git3/parallel agent skills are available:

🎯 Smart Router: Multi-Capability Detected

Your request requires:
- game-development (bmad:game-dev)
- backend-development (backend-api-dev)

RECOMMENDATION: Use parallel agent dispatch

Would you like to:
1. Use git3 to run both specialized agents concurrently (RECOMMENDED)
2. Pick one primary tool to handle both
3. Handle them sequentially

[Explain git3 workflow if user chooses option 1]

Option 2: Primary Tool

If no parallel dispatch available, pick the primary capability:

🎯 Smart Router: Multi-Capability Request

Detected needs: game-development + backend-development

Primary capability: game-development (more specialized)
Routing to: bmad:game-dev

Note: This tool can handle backend API as well, though it's primarily game-focused.

Settings Reference

Create .claude/smart-router.local.md in your project:

---
# Routing behavior
routingMode: auto          # auto | ask | context
  # auto - Always pick best automatically (fastest)
  # ask - Always show menu (most control)
  # context - Use file context to decide automatically (balanced)

# Display options
showReasoning: true        # Show why tool was chosen

# Exclusions
excludePlugins:            # Never suggest these plugins
  - ralph-wiggum           # Example: exclude test plugin
  - old-plugin

# Priority overrides
priorityOrder:             # Prefer these plugins (in order)
  - superpowers            # Always try superpowers first
  - pr-review-toolkit      # Then pr-review-toolkit
  - bmad                   # Then BMAD tools

# Context overrides (advanced)
contextRules:
  - filePattern: "*.unity"
    preferPlugins: ["bmad"]
  - filePattern: "*.test.ts"
    preferPlugins: ["superpowers"]
---

Troubleshooting

Registry not found:

• Registry builds on SessionStart
• Run /smart-router:rebuild to force rebuild
• Check .claude/.cache/agent-registry.json exists

Wrong tool selected:

• Check file context (are you in the right directory?)
• Adjust priorityOrder in settings
• Switch to ask mode to see all options

No tools suggested:

• Verify plugins are installed (~/.claude/plugins/)
• Check registry was built (SessionStart hook ran)
• Ensure capability keywords match (see registry-builder.ts)

Multiple specialists for same task:

• This is expected! (e.g., multiple code review agents)
• Use priorityOrder to set preference
• Use excludePlugins to remove unwanted options

Examples

Example 1: Auto-Routing Code Review

User: "Review this PR"

Settings: routingMode: auto

Process:

1. Load registry → finds 3 code-review tools
2. Analyze context → TypeScript backend files
3. Rank:
   • pr-review-toolkit (specialized for PRs)
   • superpowers (general)
   • feature-dev (feature branches)
4. Auto-route to pr-review-toolkit
5. Output: "🎯 Routing to pr-review-toolkit (specialized for PR review)"

Example 2: Menu Selection

User: "Help me brainstorm this feature"

Settings: routingMode: ask

Process:

1. Load registry → finds 2 brainstorming tools
2. Show menu:

   1. ⭐ superpowers:brainstorming (RECOMMENDED)
   2. bmad:core-workflows:brainstorming
   

3. User selects 1
4. Use superpowers:brainstorming skill

Example 3: Multi-Capability with Git3

User: "Build a multiplayer game with real-time backend"

Process:

1. Detect: game-development + backend-development
2. Check for git3 skills (dispatching-parallel-agents found)
3. Suggest:

   🎯 Multi-Capability Detected
   
   RECOMMENDATION: Parallel agent dispatch
   - bmad:game-dev → Game mechanics
   - backend-api-dev → Real-time API
   
   Both will work concurrently on separate branches.
   

4. If user approves, invoke dispatching-parallel-agents skill

Integration with Existing Workflows

Smart Router is designed to work alongside your existing tools, not replace them. It simply helps you discover and select the right tool when multiple options exist.

Key principle: If you already know which tool to use, use it directly. Smart Router is for discovery and decision-making when uncertain.

---

For more details on registry building and capability detection, see references/ directory.